Wednesday, August 09, 2006

Straight from the Email Box

I was pretty sure it would happen, and it has - a flood of email asking all sorts of questions about my return to a low-carb diet (defined as less than 60g net carbohydrate, where I only deduct fiber from the total carbohydrate). With a good number of emails asking the same questions, I'll answer here rather than reply individually.

Q: If you were following a low-carb diet, why do you need to lose 20-pounds again?
  • During pregnancy, while following a controlled-carb diet, I gained 60-pounds; after delivery I quickly lost 39-pounds in six weeks, while still eating controlled-carb (about 120-150g net carbs a day), so was advised to do whatever I had to to halt weight loss since it was interfering with my milk supply for nursing. After increasing calories, I lost just one more pound as I tweaked my calorie intake to prevent weight loss and weight gain....and since weaning my son, haven't reduced carbohydrate nor moderated calorie intake enough to lose weight. I haven't gained weight, but haven't lost weight....so, now I am making the necessary adjustments to my diet to lose the last of the weight gained during pregnancy.
Q: How'd you gain 20-pounds if you were eating a low-carb diet

Q: If a low-carb diet worked, you wouldn't need to lose 20-pounds after years of following it! Don't you think you should re-evaluate your diet now instead of doing what isn't working?
  • See above

Q: Why does your multivitamin have no iron?

  • My diet is rich with meats and leafy green vegetables, therefore has more than enough iron from my diet alone. Since too much iron can be problematic, I simply use a multivitamin without iron.

Q: Don't you get sick of eggs? Any ideas for breakfast other than eggs?

  • I'm not a big fan of eggs everyday, but for the first week it is a great option to include since they're packed with essential nutrients, EFA's, EAA's and are filling. For this reason, throughout weight loss they will continue to be a major food in my daily menu. If and when I tire of eggs, I'll skip a day or two and then add them back again. They're simply too rich with nutrients to not eat, in my opinion.

Q: Exposing yourself to all the hormones and antibiotics in animal products is harmful, aren't you worried about that?

  • I personally eat only pastured-meats, poultry and eggs from free-roaming (not simply cage-free) chickens; and include dairy that is from low-heat pasturized whole milk that is not homogenized, or raw (cheeses are made from raw milk); dairy is also organic, free of rBGH, antibiotics and grass-fed without grain supplementation. So the answer is, no I am not worried about exposure.

Q: Why do you include the Atkins Shake when you promote eating real whole foods?

  • During the first week, as I am focused on establishing ketosis, the addition of a protein shake (free from soy protein isolates) helps me consume enough calories since protein blunts appetite too well sometimes and retricts calorie intake too much. I target my basal metabolic rate as my minimum calorie intake, therefore need to consume at least 1800-calories per day, which is difficult when I'm eating more protein and fat than carbohydrate. I use the ready-to-drink shake since I don't like having to make it myself with the protein powder - it's less "chalky" tasting to me.

Q: Why aren't you posting how much of the food you're eating? I'd like to follow your menus and it would help if I knew how much to eat!

  • Because my consumption is based on my individual calorie requirements and not suitable for someone with lower or higher needs; therefore I post what I eat without saying how much of any food I'm consuming. Understand, at the end of the day, with the foods included, I am averaging about 20g net carbohydrate (total minus fiber only) with some days slightly less, but not more.

Q: What is your starting weight?

  • I've come to realize the number on the scale is not a reflection of health and therefore do not target a particular weight or BMI. My goal is to be as healthy as I can and right now losing 20-pounds will return my weight to my pre-pregnancy weight where I was comfortable.

Q: Are you exercising daily?

  • I chase an extremely active, almost two-year-old toddler around each day - need I say more?

Q: Isn't it unhealthy to eat that much fat?

  • Not when your body is using it as its primary source of energy

Q: Aren't you worried about eating so much protein?

  • Not at all. Especially when you consider it replaces carbohydrate as the source of the small amount of glucose needed each day.

Low-Carb Day Two

Breakfast
Omelet made with raw cheddar cheese cooked in organic butter
Coffee with heavy cream
200mcg chromium picolinate

Mid-Morning
Atkins Chocolate Protein Shake
Multivitamin w/o iron
2 Atkins Essential Oils
Coffee with heavy cream

Lunch
Leftover chicken, broccoli & bean sprouts
Fish oil
Unsweetened iced tea with fresh-squeezed lemon juice

Dinner
London broil (grilled) and green beans
500mg L-Carnetine
Water

Tuesday, August 08, 2006

Exercise & Low-Carb Diets: Phinney, Wortman, Westman

Shelley Schlender conducted interviews with Dr. Stephen Phinney, Dr. Eric Westman and Dr. Jay Wortman earlier this year during the 2006 NMS Scientific Sessions. The interviews were aired on the KGNU radio show How On Earth, For Your Health in February.

The intro: Ask most health experts how athletes should eat, and you’re likely to hear about a high carbohydrate diet—fruit, pasta, bagels, granola bars, rice. But if all this is true, how do you explain the Inuit of Northern Canada and the Arctic, who could run 30 miles a day beside their sleds, eating a diet that was 85% fat, 15% protein, and carbohydrate free? How do you explain an explorer named Stephanson who lived among the Inuit, ate what they ate, and stayed healthier than explorers eating European food? What about the professional cyclists who ate Inuit style? The more they adapted to a high fat, very low carb diet, the more they could exercise just as fast and long as they had when they were eating mostly carbs. Up next, we'll talk with three experts on low-carbohydrate diets and exercise for both the high-performance athlete and for people working to reverse health problems.

You can hear the complete show here: KGNU: How On Earth - Exercise and Low-Carb Diets.

What Does an Experienced Low-Carber Eat to Lose Weight?

With the goal to induce ketosis as quickly as possible, I ate the following yesterday:

Breakfast
Omelet made with raw cheddar cheese & baby spinach cooked in organic butter
Coffee with heavy cream
200mcg chromium picolinate

Mid-Morning
Atkins Chocolate Protein Shake
Multivitamin w/o iron
2 Atkins Essential Oils
Coffee with heavy cream

Lunch
Chef salad with mixed salad greens, cucumbers, turkey, roast beef, ham, hard boiled egg, and organic ranch dressing
Fish oil
Unsweetened iced tea with fresh-squeezed lemon juice

Dinner
Chicken stir-fry, prepared in wok with avocado oil, organic soy sauce, broccoli florets and bean sprouts
500mg L-Carnetine
Water

Monday, August 07, 2006

Baby Weights Gotta Go!

Earlier this month, Jimmy Moore challenged readers to join him in what he calls the 30-in-30 Low-Carb Weight Loss Challenge - commit to lose thirty pounds in thirty weeks following a low-carb diet with him. In today's column, he writes about the opening of the 30-in-30 blog, created to provide support and recipes for those following his challenge in the coming weeks and months.

Thus far, he's had a great response with a large number joining his challenge, including some folks already well known in the low-carb sector, like Andrew DiMino, the owner of CarbSmart.

It was Andrew's words, "I wanted you to know that like many people, I have slowly let the weight creep up on me even though I fully understand and profess the low-carb lifestyle," that led me to evaluate where I am today with my weight maintenance.

To be honest - not where I want or need to be.

While I've not re-gained all the weight lost following a low-carb/controlled-carb diet from 2001-2002, I've simply not done the work necessary to get back to the weight I'd maintained through the fall of 2003 when pregnancy necessitated a weight gain.

Okay, so I didn't "need" to gain 60-pounds during the pregnancy, but I did just that (as predicted by my OB), and today, a year after my son stopped nursing, I am back down 40-pounds, but still need to lose 20 more to be back to my pre-pregnancy weight. Like Andrew, I know exactly why I'm still not there - I haven't being eating what I know I should to lose the weight!

And, hey, my baby is now almost two years old..."it's baby fat" isn't a reasonable excuse anymore!

So, today, I'm joining Jimmy and everyone else in the challenge!

Since my goal is to lose 20-pounds (not 30), I'm modifying my personal goals to be:

  • Week 1:
    20g net carbohydrate (total minus fiber only), no calorie counting
    Anticipated weight loss: 6 pounds (the majority of which will be water weight)
  • Week 2 & 3:
    30-40g net carbohydrate (total minus fiber only), no calorie counting
    Anticipated weight loss: 4 pounds (total 10 pounds)
  • Week 4-8:
    40-60g net carbohydrate (total minus fiber only), no calorie counting
    Anticipated weight loss: 10 pounds (total 20 pounds)

Based on my past experience with a low-carb diet, I fully expect to lose the twenty pounds in eight weeks - a much shorter time period than the 30-weeks of the challenge. Since my goal is to lose 20-pounds, I've also increased the ramp up time for adding carbohydrate since I previously was able to eat 90g-125g a day and maintain without any major effort. If my revisions seem to be inhibiting my anticipated results, I'll revise and let my readers know where I'm making adjustments and why I've made them.

These days, since I do not have the time to analyze my menu each day for nutrient-density, I'll include select supplements to act as a "safety net" while still focusing on creating nutrient-dense meals each day: in addition to the multivitamin without iron and liquid fish oils I already include each day, I'll add 200mcg chromium picolinate, 500mg of Acetyl L-Carnitine, and 2 Atkins Essential Oils capsules.

I'll keep my readers updated with menus and progress each week as I move forward with the challenge. I hope that my posting my progress, along with menus and recipes will motivate those who want to try a low-carb approach to do so and join Jimmy Moore's 30-in-30 Challenge!

Thursday, August 03, 2006

Super-Sized Denial?

My first reaction to the headline, Survey: Most Obese Claim to Eat Healthy, in the Boston Globe this morning, was 'they're in denial'. A number of headlines and articles seemed to concur with my first thoughts too:

I decided to think about this one before putting pen to paper (well, fingers to keyboard) and grabbed my coffee and headed outside to enjoy the cool morning air - something the recent heat wave deterred. One position I've maintained for years now is that you simply cannot have an entire population not "get" a message of what constitutes a healthful diet when it is repeated as often as it is in the United States.

For decades now that message has been clear - a diet, with the majority of calories from carbohydrate is optimal. And here we have a survey asking individuals what they weigh, how tall they are, and how well they eat each day. When the results are such that they find most people think they're eating a healthy diet even though the majority are overweight or obese, the researchers question whether those responding were truthful and suggest, perhaps they're in denial.

This is because it is difficult to escape the notion that if you eat healthy you are going to be a normal weight. It defies out sense of logic to consider the concept of an obese person eating what is defined as a healthy diet and still be obese.

So, let's first tackle the issue of honesty by those who participated in the survey. The survey was conducted by phone from January to March of this year. The researchers contacted 11,300 individuals and found:

  • 37% were overweight (4,200)
  • 27% were obese (3,100)
  • 34% normal weight (3,800)
  • 2% were under weight (200)

This demographic result - 64% overweight or obese - is close to the current estimate of 66% overweight or obese in the US. I point this out because the survey relied on those answering to be truthful in their responses. The result of the individual responses taken collectively indicate, as a group, those providing responses may be considered honest - the demographic results for overweight or obese is within 2% of the current estimates released by public health authorities in the US and the World Health Organization.

With this in mind, let's now go through the other findings:

Of those classed as obese,

  • 75% reported they eat a healthy diet
  • 40% reported they exercise "vigorously" at least three times a week
  • 28% reported consuming snacks two or more times a day
  • 19% reported always reading labels on food packages
  • 29% reported eating out in restaurants three or more times a week

What the researchers failed to ask was what foods those responding considered "healthy," or what they ate on a daily basis. I'm not surprised these questions went unasked. Had they asked, the researchers may have uncovered the stark reality of how well the messages promoted about healthful eating have been adopted by the population in the United States.

Data on consumption trends in the United States betrays the notion that the average person eats a high-fat diet and too much protein. As a percentage of calories and in absolute grams, men in the US are consuming less fat than ever before; women are consuming less calories as fat as a percentage of their diet, but about the same in absolute grams. Protein intake over the last thirty years has remained fairly constant for both men and women.

The really radical change in our dietary habits is our consumption of carbohydrates - specifically sugars and grains; the former recommended for years as up to 25% of total calories, the latter promoted as the optimal foundation of a healthy diet. This shift in message, eat a carbohydrate-rich, low-fat diet, and change in consumption in the last thirty years has added more calories a day to the average person's diet with the average American now blamed for eating what they were told to eat...more grains without worry about the sugar, afterall, sugar is fat-free!

And now, we're told they're in denial about how they eat - they're not eating healthy, they're obese, they can't be eating healthy!

So here's my perspective on the findings - perhaps their obesity isn't simply the result of "denial" but is the reality we've set in motion with the messages over the past decades promoting the idea that an optimal diet is one low in fat and rich with carbohydrate!

Quite frankly, I've yet to meet an obese person who was totally unaware they were obese; some have tried for years to lose weight and have given up, some are currently struggling to follow the "rules" promoted by the powers that be to lose the weight, and some are just content and not going to change their habits.

I know I've watched in horror while eating out as an obese person at a table nearby chose to eat a meal that was anything but healthy; but I've also watched plenty of obese people make what they believe are good, healthy choices when they're dining out: a salad with low-fat dressing, the grilled chicken breast with pasta primavera tossed in the marinara on the side and allow themself just one piece of bread, sans any butter; a diet coke and the fruit cup for dessert. Is this an obese person in denial if they responded that they're eating healthy?

I've most certainly kept myself from saying anything as I watched an obese person pass by in the grocery store, their cart loaded to the brim with the worst foods possible; but I've also watched plenty of obese people place what they believe are healthy foods in their carts, the look of determination in their eyes - you know they're trying to watch what they eat and are trying to lose weight: whole grain bread, whole grain cereals, skim milk, fat-free yogurts, vegetables and fruits, fish and chicken, light margarine and one or two of the new "100-calorie" snack packs available, promoted as a good choice. Is this an obese person in denial if they responded they're eating healthy?

The reality is that some obese folks truly have no clue what it means to eat healthy, but I strongly believe that there are many more who truly believe they are trying to eat as healthy as they can, and do make their food selections on the message that's repeated again and again to the American public - they eat more plant-based foods (translation: eat more carbohydrates).

No matter how many times the "experts" have tweaked the message, it has remained "eat a carbohydrate-rich diet if you want to be healthy" - and the obese are doing just that.

That's not denial, that's reality folks.

Wednesday, July 26, 2006

Very Low-Fat for Diabetes? Not So Fast...

Sometimes I receive emails that are a bit amusing. Yesterday, I received a number emails asking if I was up to the task of reporting on the results from a study mentioned in Sally Squires' column, the Lean Plate Club, in the Washington Post.

The article, 'Good' Carbs To the Rescue, highlighted findings published in the May 1 issue of the American Journal of Cardiology in the paper, Comparison of Coronary Risk Factors and Quality of Life in Coronary Artery Disease Patients With Versus Without Diabetes Mellitus. One email asked if I truly believed in reporting the findings from studies contrary to my own beliefs about diet and nutrition.

To answer that simply - yes, I can, I do and I have in the past in this column!

With regard to this particular study - I hadn't seen it previously and can say after reading through the paper, I did find the results intriguing, yet lacking in the detail expected when subjects with diagnoised diabetes are included in a study that specifically modifies diet as part of the design.

In the above study, researchers sought to investigate the effect of dietary modification in those with coronary artery disease (CAD), some of the subjects included also had diabetes. The subjects included 440 individuals - 347 men (55 with diabetes) and 93 women (36 with diabetes). All were placed on a very low-fat vegan/vegetarian diet (target 10% or less calories from fat), provided weekly counseling and support, and advised to exercise and practice stress management daily as they were followed for one-year.

For the purpose of this article, I am going to focus on the subjects with diagnoised diabetes since the article written by Ms. Squires focused on this group in her opening sentences - "People with Type 2 diabetes are advised to limit carbohydrates because of worries that too many carbs could overtax the body's dwindling insulin production and lessen its ability to process glucose...Now some scientists are asking if a very-low-fat diet rich in healthy carbohydrates -- whole grains, beans, fruit and vegetables -- might be another option."

Over the period of one-year, the researchers tracked changes in BMI, weight, cholesterol levels, blood pressure, exercise capacity, changes in medication requirement, and physical and emotional health.

Unfortunately, the researchers did not track, or at least did not publish, changes in fasting glucose, glucose tolerance, insulin levels, HbA1C or other risk markers considered important to evaluate in those with diabetes.

This lack of detail makes the data that is published in the study much more difficult to evaluate for efficacy in those with diabetes.

As I noted, the researchers did publish details about the number of subjects taking diabetic medications at baseline and at one-year. Of the 91 followed for the year, 5 dropped out so we have no data for their medication changes; 62 experienced no change in their medication regiment; 12 discontinued their diabetes medications; 6 no longer required insulin but did require an oral antiglycemic; and 6 experienced a worsening of their condition that required medication not taken at baseline.

Why lacking details are important:

  • Of the 62 who did not change medication, 16 started with no medication and remained free of diabetic medication requirements. That's a good thing and I believe this sub-set should have been reported as a separate group.
  • Of the remaining 46 reported as "no changes" in medication, we are provided no detail about dosing requirements! While their medication regiment (oral or insulin) may not have changed, we have no details as to whether their dosage increased, remained the same or decreased during the period of one year. This data is critical to understand if this type of dietary intervention is slowing progression of the disease or not.
  • In the 6 subjects who experienced a worsening of their condition we are also not provided details to better understand why their condition may or may not have been made worse by the diet and/or lifestyle interventions of the study.

In her column, Ms. Squires writes, "Blood levels of low-density lipoprotein (LDL), "bad" cholesterol that raises heart disease risk, dropped. Levels of protective high-density lipoprotein (HDL) didn't drop, and unhealthy fats known as triglycerides didn't rise, as some researchers had feared."

However, when we read through the data, the reduction in LDL cholesterol did not reach statistical significance in those with diabetes; HDL remained unchanged in the diabetic women and declined slightly in the diabetic men (not statistically significant); and the triglycerides declined slightly in the diabetic men and rose in the diabetic women (not statistically significant), remaining well above the "high risk" target of 200mg/dl in both the men and women.

The last piece of critical data missing is details about the diet composition. We are provided only one small piece of data - the fat content, as percentage of calories. The fat content was 14.2% in the diabetic men and 19% in the diabetic women when they started the dietary modification (baseline). This was significantly modified in the trial - at one-year the men consumed 6.4% of total calories as fat and the women 8.9% of calories as fat.

What we don't know is just as important - how many calories did they consume at baseline and after one-year? How much protein? How many carbohydrates? How much fiber? What type of carbohydrates? What did the micronutrient profile look like at baseline and one-year? What did they eat to achieve the consumption pattern? How did calorie intake and composition change from baseline to one-year? There are more unknowns here than I believe is acceptable in a study modifying diet!

My last concern with the study is that it was a multi-faceted intervention: diet, exercise, stress management and intensive support. On its face, these modifications are all considered good interventions and worthy of investigation in a controlled trial. The problem lies with teasing out which ones were meaningful in the results. Was it the diet, the exercise, the reduction of stress, the support, the weight loss from diet and exercise, or a combination of two or more? We don't know because each potentially plays a role and each is considered a "confounding variable" if not controlled for specifically.

While I applaud the researchers for convincing a good number of individuals to stick with this trial for the year - a very low-fat vegan/vegetarian diet is extremely difficult to follow faithfully - the fact remains the published data remains lacking in sufficient data and control that could have been included.

Noticably absent is critical data for those with diabetes - levels of glucose, insulin and HbA1C; glossed over is the fact that in those with diabetes, LDL was not reduced significantly, HDL remained low in both men and women and men had a minor decrease in the year, and triglycerides remained at levels considered "high risk," and actually rose in the women with diabetes.

The lack of statistically significant improvements in those with diabetes means we should look at this study with caution because what we have here is study that is not as impressive as we're led to believe in the media reporting of the findings when we actually go to the data and read through the findings ourselves.

Tuesday, July 25, 2006

Study Claims High-Carb/Low-GI Diet Optimizes Reduction in Cardiovascular Risk

I was a bit surprised by the conclusions reached in the recent issue of the Archives of Internal Medicine - Comparison of 4 Diets of Varying Glycemic Load on Weight Loss and Cardiovascular Risk Reduction in Overweight and Obese Young Adults - in which researchers concluded that "Both high-protein and low-GI regimens increase body fat loss, but cardiovascular risk reduction is optimized by a high-carbohydrate, low-GI diet."

So, as you may have guessed - I was off to reading the full-text and data to understand how the conclusion was reached.

As suspected, total cholesterol and LDL were the ever "all important" markers used to determine cardiovascular risk reduction.

Each time I come upon another study that fails to include other potent measures of cardiovascular risk as part of the conclusions, I'm less surprised. Some days it seems the diet-heart-lipid hypothesis is so entrenched in the conventional wisdom we're doomed to just keep on keeping on with it, stumbling along while ignoring other critical markers in our "vein" [pun intended] attempt to convince the population to eat less fat while continuing to eat a diet rich with carbohydrate!

Who are they kidding?

For one thing, the study was just twelve weeks - as we hear so often from the low-carbohydrate diet critics, such a short period is way too little time to make such a sweeping conclusion that reduction of cardiovascular risk is "optimized" by a diet. And you know what, twelve weeks is too little time! I've never had an issue with that criticism leveled at studies of short duration for low-carbohydrate diets. I do take issue with dietary studies of similar short duration touted as examples to "optimize" reduction of cardiovascular risk!

Add to that the researchers make no mention of the insignificant reduction to blood glucose, the miniscule increase in HDL, the almost non-existent reduction in triglycerides nor the inconsequential down tick in glucose levels. These other risk markers had no spectacular improvements, yet the researchers concluded the high carbohydrate-low GI diet offered "optimized" cardiovascular risk reduction.

Reducing the risk of cardiovascular disease is a lot more than just getting total cholesterol and LDL heading south - I believe they also need to happen in conjunction with other overall improvements - significant reduction in triglycerides, improved glycemic control, improved insulin and improvements in TC:HDL and HDL:TG. At the end of the day, LDL may not be the end-all be all marker we make it when we look at the bigger picture with what may be more important risk markers.

While the old guard still holds sway and appears to influence researcher conclusions to focus on LDL and total cholesterol, there is compelling evidence (as I've pointed out previously) that we must be investigating other markers if we're going to truly make a difference in the lives of millions with or at risk for cardiovascular disease.

When we look at the total list of risk markers we find the high carbohydrate-low GI diet was not necessarily the "optimal" diet for long-term cardiovascular health. In fact, none of the diets were all that spectacular with overall improvements to stand out. In this particular study, the results at twelve weeks were so mixed they're really clinically insignificant in my view, especially if the intent of such studies is to increase our knowledge and significantly impact all markers in those at risk.

If we aspire to take a broader view of risk reduction and seek to really improve overall health, a good example is found in the study published last year by Yancy et al. I highlight this study because of the similar duration and calorie intake with focus on low carbohydrate, which is naturally low for glycemic index and glycemic load, but dramatically different macronutrient mix for consumption of carbohydrate, protein and fat. It is probably the best to use here in an attempt for an apples-to-apples comparison.

Yancy et al included just 38.9g average carbohydrate, 93.5g average total fat and 98.5g protein in 1418 calories; McMillian-Price et al (above) included 200g carbohydrate, 36g total fat and 63g protein in 1438 calories. Yancy et al does not detail consumption of saturated fat, but it's a fair assumption it was significantly higher for dieters in his study given the total fat intake along with the higher protein intake.

If dietary fat is truly detrimental - especially saturated fat - we should see some major increased risks in those following the diet in Yancy, right?

Funny thing - we find significantly greater improvements in those subjects following the diet in Yancy than we do in McMillan. With one glaring exception - LDL cholesterol. Let's take a look:

Weight Loss
Yancy 131.4kg reduced to 122.7kg (-8.7kg)
McMillian-Price 87.1kg reduced to 82.3kg (-4.8kg)
(to be fair, Yancy et al was an additional four weeks in duration)

Total Cholesterol
Yancy 4.61 reduced to 4.54 (-0.70)
McMillian-Price 4.71 reduced to 4.53 (-0.18)

HDL
Yancy .92 increased to .99 (+0.07)
McMillian-Price 1.16 increased to 1.21 (+0.05)

LDL
Yancy 2.51 increased to 2.77 (+0.26)
McMillian-Price 2.9 reduced to 2.73 (-0.17)

Triglycerides
Yancy 2.69 reduced to 1.57 (-1.12)
McMillian-Price 1.39 reduced to 1.34 (-0.05)

TC:HDL Ratio
Yancy 5 reduced to 4.5 (-0.50)
McMillian-Price 4.16 reduced to 3.95 (-0.21)

TG:HDL Ratio
Yancy 2.92 reduced to 1.58 (-1.34)
McMillian-Price 1.19 reduced to 1.10 (-0.09)

Glucose
Yancy 9.8 reduced to 7.57 (-2.23)
McMillian-Price 4.95 reduced to 4.88 (-0.06)

The question begs - why are we still bent on LDL cholesterol as an end-all-be-all marker of improvement or reduction of risk? It's clear from the data above that subjects experienced greater overall improvements following the low-carbohydrate diet than they did following the high carbohydrate-low GI diet that was also low in fat and protein.

It's pretty easy to do the math - McMillian et al provided 22% of calories a fat (36g in 1417 calories) and Yancy et al provided 59.3% of calories as fat (93.5g in 1418 calories).

The subjects in Yancy et al consumed not only relatively more fat (percentage of calories), but absolutely more fat (grams consumed daily) - they ate 3-times the fat as those in McMillian et al. In fact, those in the Yancy et al study consumed more fat than the average American does each day if the American Heart Association numbers are correct at 81.4g total fat per day per person!

They ate more fat and still had greater improvements in the broader list of risk markers, except their LDL increased slightly.

But, after decades of being told it's the dietary fat we must reduce (with no convincing data), we're now seeing a transition in the message to eat a diet that is low in fat and low GI, but still rich with carbohydrate. Aside from both diets offering the ability to lose weight, the data above clearly shows that after twelve weeks, other than LDL cholesterol levels, no other significant improvements were found in subjects following the high-carbohydrate/low-GI/low-fat diet.

While it is politically correct to reach such a conclusion, it's again a great example of how dogma can over-ride hard data. Shouldn't a conclusion of "optimized" reduction of cardiovascular risk also include HDL? Triglycerides? Glucose? Insulin? TC:HDL ratio? TG:HDL ratio?

The hard data here is that none of the four dietary interventions McMillian et al investigated did much of anything in twelve weeks other than allow for some weight loss and two of the four resulted in a reduction in LDL.

Simply put - that's not enough time nor improvement to make a sweeping and strong conclusion that a high carbohydrate, low-GI diet (the one that reduced LDL the most) optimizes cardiovascular risk reduction!

Tuesday, July 18, 2006

AHA Offers More Details to 2006 Diet & Lifestyle Recommendations

The American Heart Association has yet to provide a single day (or seven-day) menu to provide details to the public or healthcare providers about how to follow their new 2006 Diet & Lifestyle Recommendations issued last month.

In my June 22nd challenge, I placed a $1,000 reward for anyone who can design a menu that meets the AHA guideline restricting saturated fat to less than 7% of total calories while also meeting all essential nutrient requirements (vitamins, minerals, trace elements, essential fatty acids and essential amino acids) and is within the AHA guidelines for cholesterol, sodium and types of foods to include (or avoid).

I almost expected the AHA would immediately submit a menu to my challenge to prove it can be done. I mean, hey, they have a team of nutrition experts to call on and compile such a menu fairly quickly (if it can be done), right?

Well, instead of posting a menu to help someone understand how to follow their new guideline, they've included a guideline detailing how many servings of each food group should be included in a daily menu to comply with their guidelines. For those taking part in the challenge, it is a requirement to follow all AHA recommendations, including this new set of information regarding number of servings from each food group.

Which places those who have already submitted a menu that failed at a disadvantage - the AHA hadn't provided clear guidance previously at the start of the challenge to guide the design of a menu. So, in the spirit of good sportsmanship, I am extending an invitation for re-submission of a revised menu to those who previously submitted a menu who would like to try again with a menu based on this more detailed information.

Since the challenge menu requires 1956-calories (+/- 5 calories), designed for a female-30, the following guideline is provided by the AHA:
  • Grains:
    6-8 servings a day; half from whole grain sources
  • Vegetables:
    4-5 servings a day
  • Fruits:
    4-5 servings a day
  • Fat-free or low-fat dairy:
    2-3 servings a day
  • Lean meats, poultry, seafood:
    Less than 6-ounces (cooked) a day
  • Fats and oils:
    2-3 servings a day
  • Nuts, seeds and legumes:
    4-5 servings per week
  • Sweets and added sugars:
    Less than 5 per week

Details about what constitutes a serving size is available on the AHA website.

To date none of the menus I've received comply with the above serving recommendaitons issued by the AHA. And, so far none I've finished analyzing meet the challenge requirement to be within the AHA guidelines and provide for essential nutrients. If you've previously submitted a menu and it was found to be deficient, you may try again at this time since the AHA has provided more detail since the challenge started. If a menu submitted is currently under review, and is not within the above guideline, I will return it to you for revision to allow you to create a menu within the above standard issued by the AHA.

Oh, and if you haven't yet tried to do a menu - go for it, I have $1,000 sitting here for the first person who creates a menu that includes the above servings for each food group and meets all the other challenge requirements detailed previously!

Good Luck!

Thursday, July 13, 2006

Is It Time to Rethink the Traditional Risk Factors for Heart Disease?

This week's Archives of Internal Medicine had an interesting study published - An Assessment of Incremental Coronary Risk Prediction Using C-Reactive Protein and Other Novel Risk Markers: The Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities Study - in which researchers investigated the clinical utility of 19 "novel" risk markers for predicting cardiovascular disease compared with the traditional risk markers currently used by clinicans in practice today.

The cover graphic quickly provides a glimpse at the traditional risk markers and the "novel" markers currently making headlines as potentially important as part of the risk assessment with patients.



After reviewing these novel markers compared to the traditional risk markers, the researchers concluded that "Our findings suggest that routine measurement of these novel markers is not warranted for risk assessment. On the other hand, our findings reinforce the utility of major, modifiable risk factor assessment to identify individuals at risk for CHD for preventive action."

In an accompanying editorial, Predicting Cardiovascular Risk, Dr. Donald Llyod-Jones included a stunning comment followed by a critical question, "It is possible that, to date, we have examined the wrong novel risk markers. Should we seek as yet undiscovered markers that will improve risk prediction substantially when added to established risk factors?"

He continued with a caveat - "Such markers will need to be highly associated with CHD, uncorrelated with established risk factors, have a reasonable prevalence of risk-producing levels in the population, and not increase competing risks for other diseases. Where will we find such markers?"

But then, adds more questions, "Should we start again and create new CVD risk prediction models without guaranteeing inclusion of established risk factors? Would this be of clinical value? How would we know what to treat?"

And then asks an incredibly important question, "Do we perhaps need a different goal? Rather than identifying high-risk individuals for drug therapy, should we try to optimize identification of low-risk individuals and attempt to move the population profile toward this ideal through public health interventions?"

As I read through Dr. Llyod-Jones' editorial I was struck by the questions and the simplicity of exploring alternative risk prediction models. The literature is rich with data - much largely ignored when it comes to heart disease since we're entrenched in the belief that cholesterol and saturated fat are the culprits in heart disease.

But if we start with his last item - identifying low-risk individuals - we find something potentially ground-breaking, that's often not considered as we debate how to assess risk for heart disease - who can provide us with a good picture of long term health?

Centenarians - those who live to be 100 or older around the world. You don't live to be 100 without something important going on - and I contend, it's not just genetics.

We know those who live to be 100 or more are a very diverse group - their longevity isn't consistently based on moderate alcohol consumption, smoking habits, country of origin, or ethnicity. And we also know that cholesterol values, overall diet and levels of activity vary greatly. In fact, we know there are only three things that link centenarians around the world - relatively low blood glucose, strong insulin sensitivity and low triglycerides.

That's it - in study after study, these three things are the only three things that are shared "common denominators" in those 100 or older.

The question then begs - if strong insulin sensitivity, low triglycerides and low blood glucose are the common ties-that-bind centenarians together as a group, should these metabolic markers be our new starting point to understand and reduce the risk of heart disease?

A quick review of the literature suggests the answer is "yes."

An article in the May 16, 2006 issue of New Scientist had an interesting quote from Dr. Andrzej Bartke, a researcher at Southern Illinois University, "Insulin resistance is a risk factor for just about any problem you don't want to get: diabetes, atherosclerosis, cancer. It's sort of intuitive that the opposite situation would be beneficial."

The opposite, of course, is strong insulin sensitivity.

But we do have to ask - does strong insulin sensitivity confer any health benefit? In reverse, is there evidence that higher levels of insulin, and thus blood glucose and triglycerides, increase heath risks? Basically, does higher insulin, blood gluocse and triglycerides have a detrimental effect?

Interestingly, several studies show the atherogenic effects of high blood glucose and insulin:

2002 - American Journal of Hypertention; Correlates of aortic stiffness in elderly individuals: a subgroup of the Cardiovascular Health Study

"Mean aortic pulse wave velocity (850 cm/sec, range 365 to 1863) did not differ by ethnicity or sex. Increased aortic stiffness was positively associated with higher systolic blood pressure (SBP), age, fasting and 2-h postload glucose, fasting and 2-h insulin, triglycerides, waist circumference, body mass index, truncal fat, decreased physical activity, heart rate, and common carotid artery wall thickness (P < .05)...In these elderly participants, aortic stiffness was positively associated with risk factors associated with the insulin resistance syndrome, increased common carotid intima-media thickness, heart rate, and decreased physical activity measured several years earlier."

March 2001 - American Journal of Epidemiology; Metabolic syndrome and ischemic heart disease in elderly men and women

"In both men and women, three uncorrelated principal components were identified, representing a central metabolic factor (body mass index, fasting and 2-hour serum insulin, high serum triglycerides, and low HDL cholesterol), a glucose factor, and a blood pressure factor. In a multivariate model with age and sex, all three factors were significantly associated with IHD by electrocardiogram criteria; central metabolic factor, glucose factor, blood pressure factor, age (10 years), and female sex. Similar results were obtained in analyses using clinically manifest IHD as the outcome. These results support the thesis that the metabolic syndrome exerts effects through different risk factors by different mechanisms."

April 2000 - European Journal of Clinical Investigation; Effects of glucose ingestion on cardiac autonomic nervous system in healthy centenarians: differences with aged subjects

"In aged subject (AS), but not in healthy centenarians (HC), the baseline low frequency/high frequency ratio (LF/HF) correlated significantly with BMI, waist-hip-ratio (WHR), fasting plasma insulin, and norepinephrine concentration. Glucose ingestion was associated with a significant rise in LF/HF ratio in both groups studied but per cent changes in glucose mediated stimulation of LF/HF was lower in HC than in AS...Our study demonstrates that basal- and glucose-stimulated LF/HF, an indirect index of cardiac sympatho-vagal balance, are lower in HC than in AS."

January 2000 - European Journal of Clinical Investigation; Insulin resistance, lipid and fatty acid concentrations in 867 healthy Europeans. European Group for the Study of Insulin Resistance (EGIR)

"The associations of fasting triglycerides with the M-value and with nonesterified fatty acid (NEFA) at steady state were independent of each other. All these associations were independent of obesity and geographical location...The results in this large cohort of healthy European subjects suggest that triglyceride concentrations depend upon both insulin's gluco-regulation (estimated by glucose uptake) and antilipolytic insulin action (measured by NEFA levels) during an euglycaemic clamp."

April 1998 - Annals of Internal Medicine; Metabolic risk factors worsen continuously across the spectrum of nondiabetic glucose tolerance. The Framingham Offspring Study

"Multivariable-adjusted mean measures of risk factors and odds ratios for obesity, elevated waist-to-hip ratio, hypertension, low levels of high-density lipoprotein cholesterol, elevated triglyceride levels, and hyperinsulinemia showed continuous increases across the spectrum of nondiabetic glucose tolerance. Although a threshold effect near the upper range of nondiabetic glucose tolerance could not be ruled out for triglyceride levels in men and for insulin levels 2 hours after oral challenge in men and women, no other metabolic risk factors showed clear evidence of thresholds for increased risk...Metabolic risk factors for type 2 diabetes mellitus and for cardiovascular disease worsen continuously across the spectrum of glucose tolerance categories, beginning in the lowest quintiles of normal fasting glucose level."

February 1998 - Diabetes Care; U-shaped and J-shaped relationships between serum insulin and coronary heart disease in the general population. The Bruneck Study

"Results of the present study suggest that both hyperinsulinemia and "hypoinsulinemia" are independent indicators of CHD. Furthermore, it is proposed that the relationship between CHD and fasting insulin is U-shaped, whereas that between CHD and postglucose insulin may be J-shaped."

April 1998 - Metabolism; Insulin resistance and fat patterning with aging: relationship to metabolic risk factors for cardiovascular disease

"No index of overall obesity, fat patterning, glucose/insulin metabolism, and/or SI, was independently related to the plasma concentration of HDL-C after controlling for any one of the other two. Direct measurement of glucose/insulin metabolism and insulin sensitivity (SI), as well as fat patterning, provides information on their relative associations with CVD risk factors. The measures of glucose/insulin metabolism and SI were more consistently related to dyslipidemia and hypertension than were the overall obesity and fat patterning in this healthy population."

March 2006 - Journal of the American Geriatric Society; Impaired fasting glucose is associated with increased arterial stiffness in elderly people without diabetes mellitus: the Rotterdam Study

"In the total cohort, fasting glucose was strongly associated with carotid distensibility...IFG is related to arterial stiffness in elderly subjects. An advanced stage of arterial stiffness, comparable with that of subjects with DM, is only reached at the age of 75."

April 1994 - Arteriosclerosis and thrombosis; Hyperinsulinemia predicts multiple atherogenic changes in lipoproteins in elderly subjects

"Baseline insulin level was not significantly associated with the development of high LDL cholesterol or low HDL cholesterol levels. Baseline insulin was associated with the development of hypertriglyceridemia."

January 1991 - Arteriosclerosis and thrombosis; High fasting plasma insulin is an indicator of coronary heart disease in non-insulin-dependent diabetic patients and nondiabetic subjects

"The results suggest that hyperinsulinemia is an indicator of CHD in both NIDDM patients and nondiabetic subjects. Hyperinsulinemia may be directly atherogenic, but it is more probable that hyperinsulinemia reflects insulin resistance, which may be a factor enhancing atherogenesis by causing adverse changes in many CHD risk factors."

November 2002 - International Journal of Cardiology; Fasting insulin levels independently associated with coronary heart disease in non-diabetic Turkish men and women

"Hyperinsulinemia (i) may provide information on the coronary heart disease likelihood over and above that provided by the other risk factors, including HDL-cholesterol, and (ii) may contribute, within the frame of insulin resistance, to the coronary heart disease risk independently of the classical risk factors."

January 2006 - Diabetes Care; Relation Between Blood Glucose and Coronary Mortality Over 33 Years in the Whitehall Study

"A threshold model with linear slope best described the dose-response relationship between postload blood glucose and CHD mortality risk."

The above are just a dozen studies randomly selected that are available in the literature - many more exist and are easily accessible in PubMed.com. To me, they highlight the pressing need to step back from our obession with dietary fats, which are, on their own, pretty much metabolically neutral, and re-evaluate the influcence our diet rich with carbohydrates, especially refined carbohydrates, is exerting on our long-term health.

This isn't rocket science - a very basic understanding of metabolism and metabolic pathways explains exactly how and why excessive carbohydrate consumption contributes to not only obesity, but insulin resistance, and thus heart disease.

Some of the most depressing studies available today are those investigating the cardiovascular health of children, already well on the road to diabetes, cardiovascular disease and a reduced life expectancy.

June 2003 - Obesity Research; Fasting plasma insulin modulates lipid levels and particle sizes in 2- to 3-year-old children

"Fasting insulin level was positively correlated with triglyceride levels and inversely correlated with HDL-cholesterol level in boys. Higher fasting insulin level was also correlated with smaller mean HDL particle size in both boys and girls and smaller mean LDL particle size in boys. The associations of fasting insulin level with triglyceride and HDL-cholesterol levels and HDL and LDL particle size remained significant after multivariate regression adjustment for age, sex, and BMI or ponderal index. Fasting insulin level is associated with relative dyslipidemia in healthy 2- and 3-year-old Hispanic children."

Two and three year old children, already experiencing the health damaging effects of high insulin and high triglycerides!

Yet, the "traditional" risk factors [see graphic above] do not include insulin levels, blood glucose or triglycerides in weighing an individuals risk for heart disease. It is only when an individual has progressed to diabetes that their metabolic condition is acknowledged to be the risk factor it is. The above studies clearly demonstrate the detrimental effects long before someone presents with diabetes!

While the study above explored the value of 19 additional potentially useful risk factors, noticiably absent are three that should have been considered - insulin, glucose and triglycerides.

I'd like to applaud Dr. Llyod-Jones for pointing out that our current thinking may be impeding our efforts to reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease.

Staring us in the face is the potent value of measuring insulin and insulin sensitivity, blood glucose and triglycerides - these, at low values, are the shared traits in centenarians around the world; and it is these same markers, at elevated levels, that are found again and again in studies where cardiovascular disease is an issue.

We've spent decades - and billions of dollars - convincing ourselves it is dietary fat that increases the risk of heart disease. I really have to wonder how much time we're going to continue to demonize dietary fat and cholesterol, while ignoring the data that insulin, blood glucose and triglycerides are strong predictors of cardiovascular disease and/or longevity.

How much longer can we afford to ignore the increased consumption of carbohydrates in the US? How much longer can we afford to ignore the lasting damage high insulin, blood sugar and triglycerides exact on our children and their long-term health?

How much longer until Americans wake up and demand the leading health organizations take the evidence seriously enough to step back and question the current paradigm, evaluate the role of excessive carbohydrate in disease, and base recommendations on science not dogma?

Friday, July 07, 2006

Milk - It Does a Body Good?

MSNBC reported on a study published in the July issue of Diabetes Care - A prospective study of dairy intake and the risk of type 2 diabetes in women conducted by researchers at UCLA.

The article, Low-fat dairy may lower women’s diabetes risk, opens with "A diet that includes lots of low-fat dairy products may lower the risk of type 2 diabetes in women, new research suggests," and continues with details of the just published study where researchers "looked for the relationship between type 2 diabetes and dietary levels of dairy foods and calcium in 37,183 women in the Women’s Health Study. A total of 1,603 women developed diabetes during an average follow-up of 10 years."

The lead researcher, Dr. Simin Liu, from the University of California Los Angeles School of Public Health noted he and his colleagues undertook the investigation because a series of recent studies suggests that a high level of dairy foods in the diet may lower the risk of being overweight or developing insulin resistance syndrome, studies that have examined the link between these factors and diabetes risk are sparse.

When I first started to read through the data, I was struck by just how many confounding factors they "adjusted" to reach their significant findings!
  • BMI
  • smoking status
  • physical activity
  • family history of diabetes
  • alcohol consumption
  • history of hypertension
  • use of hormones
  • high cholesterol

After "adjusting" for these inconvenient variables, the researchers concluded "A dietary pattern that incorporates higher low-fat dairy products may lower the risk of type 2 diabetes in middle-aged or older women."

They didn't add IF you're normal weight, don't smoke, are active, don't have a family history of diabetes, drink in moderation, don't have a family history of high blood pressure, aren't using hormones and don't have high cholesterol. Basically, they forgot to add the findings apply to those who are in good health!

Which begs the question - was it the inclusion of dairy or was it an overall better dietary and lifestyle pattern that kept these women in good health?

The problem with studies such as this is they're focused only on one particular in a dietary pattern that includes a wide variety of other foods. Add to that lifestyle, genetics and family history and it's impossible to say with any certainty that one particular food or food group is protective against disease. It's a leap of faith to say eating more dairy lowers the risk of type 2 diabetes without considering those confounding variables that were conveniently "adjusted" out of the equation.

I hate to say it, but this isn't science. If you ask me, it seems more like a manipulation of data to promote the dairy industry and the consumption of milk and dairy products.

Hey, I like dairy - I eat natural cheese, whole milk yogurt and occassionally even enjoy some good homemade ice cream - but do I need to include dairy to prevent diabetes? No

Reducing the risk of diabetes comes down to two things - eating a nutrient-rich diet and staying active. Sure, dairy can be part of that equation, but it's not an essential food, holds no magical metabolic protection and is an absolute nightmare for those who are lactose intolerant.

Wednesday, July 05, 2006

Carbohydrates - How Much is Too Much?

In the Lancet this week, researchers published a chilling finding - Diabetes confers an equivalent risk to ageing 15 years - in Relation between age and cardiovascular disease in men and women with diabetes compared with non-diabetic people: a population-based retrospective cohort study.

As reported in Forbes, "...the most striking numbers in the report involved life expectancy. People with type 2 diabetes who were also classified as being at moderate or high risk for cardiovascular disease died an average of about 18 years earlier than non-diabetics, the researchers found."

I don't know about you, but I find it disturbing that we now estimate one-third of adults in the United States have or at risk for type II diabetes and we're still making the same recommendations for diet that have done nothing to reverse, or even slow the ever-increasing incidence of the disease in the last thirty years.

Throughout the medical and scientific literature there is a wealth of data correlating glycemic control, and insulin and blood glucose levels, with cardiovascular disease. These findings are consistent in those with and without type II diabetes.

Back in 1988, the Paris Prospective Study, published in the International Journal of Obesity, found "The strength of the association of blood pressure to the risk was reduced when BMI increased. By contrast, the association of blood pressure to the risk remained linear when plasma insulin level rather than BMI was considered. Plasma insulin level was a more sensitive marker of CHD risk than glucose intolerance in the overweight group. Moreover, in this group, the relation to CHD mortality risk was stronger for plasma insulin level than for blood pressure."

In 1998, the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism published a study in which researchers concluded that "In conclusion, approximately one of every five healthy, nonobese subjects in the most insulin-resistant tertile, followed for approximately 5 yr, had a serious clinical event. These data highlight the importance of insulin resistance as a predictor of CVD."

In JAMA in April 2004, researchers published findings from subjects with normal glucose tolerance - a cohort of 234 men were investigated and the researchers concluded that "For patients with NGT and different extents of atherosclerotic disease, postload glycemia and HbA1c level are not equally distributed but are significantly higher in those with more severe disease. This suggests that the glycemic milieu correlates with the cardiovascular risk according to a linear model."

Let's not forget, earlier this year, a study was published after following 18,403 men for thirty-three years. The researchers found that ten years into the study, heart disease mortality started to increase at blood sugar levels above 95 mg/dl, but that those subjects with blood sugar levels below 95 mg/dl showed no increased risk for death from heart disease. After 33-years, the increased risk for heart disease started at blood glucose levels of 83mg/dL - with a linear increase in risk between 83mg/dL and 95mg/dL.

To date, not one study has been published with similar correlations to cholesterol levels.

In fact, the researchers in the above study measured cholesterol levels and found no significant difference in cholesterol levels between those subjects with normal blood sugar, those who were glucose intolerant, and those diagnoised with diabetes. Over thirty-three years it wasn't the cholesterol levels that mattered - it was blood sugars!

And here we are today, still preaching cholesterol, cholesterol, cholesterol; saturated fat, saturated fat, saturated fat as the only dietary means to reduce heart disease. Folks - it's not the cholesterol, and it's not the saturated fat - it's the blood sugars and resulting insulin resistance from years of excessive carbohydrate consumption!

Every single time you consume more carbohydrate than your body needs, it's excessive - and it's placing a burden on your metabolism to deal with the excess.

Just how long do you think your metabolism can keep humming along with too much blood sugar? How much time passes before repeated highs in blood sugars, and resulting highs in insulin, do damage to your cardiovascular system?

Don't fool yourself into thinking there are "good carbs" and "bad carbs" - there are only carbohydrates; some providing essential nutrients with a small amount of carbohydrate and others that are nutritionally bankrupt and/or providing too much carbohydrate-load to the body at one time. Both simple and complex carbohydrate is metabolized to glucose in the body - the former just faster than the latter.

Eating too many complex carbohydrates results in the same level of blood glucose as eating too many refined or simple carbohydrates - and both result in a higher demand for insulin to stablize blood sugars. Even the American Diabetes Association (ADA) acknowledges "[t]he total amount of carbohydrate consumed is a strong predictor of glycemic response."

Over time, this rollercoaster of high blood sugars, demand for more insulin to reduce blood sugars within a tight range of normal and increasing insulin resistance is damaging to not only the metabolism, but to cardiovascular health. At some point, the body simply has to make compromises when it is assaulted day in and day out by foods that damage its ability to function properly.

The food you choose to eat has a direct and lasting effect on how well your body functions - eat the wrong foods repeatedly and your body and metabolism will be damaged over time. Consume foods that optimize your metabolic function while nourishing your body, and your body will thank you with good health.

Good health is the default human condition - when you find yourself in an unhealthy state, it's time to assess where you can make improvements to enhance your well-being to restore good health. Our bodies are designed for good health - it's the normal state we are supposed to enjoy each day! Yet, too many of us accept poor health as normal and convince ourselves that it's just part of life.

You do not have to accept poor health as your fate.

There are simple modifications one can make to their diet to increase essential nutrient intake and reduce the damaging effects of high blood sugars and insulin. Creating a health enhancing diet starts with eliminating the excessive carbohydrate from your diet - this type of diet is built on our knowledge of the athrogenic effects of high blood sugars and insulin in the body.

In May of this year researchers published the study, The atherogenic potential of dietary carbohydrate, and concluded "High-carbohydrate diets, particularly in the form of high-glycemic index carbohydrate, have the ability to directly induce atherosclerosis. Based on anthropologic facts, the reason for these dietary-induced, insulin-mediated, atherogenic metabolic perturbations are suggested to be an insufficient adaptation to starch and sugars during human evolution. Restriction of insulinogenic food (starch and sugars) may help to prevent the development of atherosclerosis, one of the most common and costliest human diseases."

The first step is to lay the foundation of nutrients we know are critical for good health - amino acids, fatty acids and vitamins, minerals and trace elements. These essential nutrients are provided by meats, poultry, fish, game, eggs, nuts, seeds, fats/oils, fruits, legumes and non-starchy vegetables.

That's it - we don't need any grains for health, and certainly don't need any refined or processed foods.

But, we like them.

They taste good.

And, we've built our entire dietary recommendations around them - established grains as the foundation of our diet rather than nutrient-dense foods. Today, we're paying the price for our dietary myths - we're eating excessive carbohydrate and thus, consuming too many calories and getting too fat because of the metabolic rollercoster caused by what we eat. In the process, we're watching our children suffer with type II diabetes, increasing our dependance on pharmaceutical solutions to our ills and accepting poor health as somehow normal when we age.

With so many "experts" claiming that low-carb and/or controlled-carb diets are unhealthy, it's difficult to consider their health redeeming benefits. But, a number researchers have published data that supports such a dietary approach as a way to reduce weight, stabilize blood sugars, reduce insulin resistance, reduce HbA1C levels, improve blood pressure and even improve cholesterol. These studies are consistently ignored and dismissed while the established low-fat dogma persists and our health continues to decline.

The only word that describes our current situation in the United States is "crisis" - we are in a national health crisis today and rather than base recommendations on clear data, we're seeing the leading health authorities dig in their heels and repeat the dietary advice I believe is directly contributing to our declining health.

It isn't all that difficult to understand that when you tell a population to reduce total fat and strictly limit saturated fat and cholesterol they're going to eat more carbohydrate to compensate for the calories lost by limiting protein and fat.

Take that to the next step, and it's not that difficult to understand that shifting consumption of calories to more carbohydrate stimulates more insulin to control higher blood sugars that result from consumption of more carbohydrate. The unintended consequence being that hunger is triggered more often with highs and lows in blood sugar and insulin triggering hunger more often, leading to an increase in calories eaten each day, leading to consumption of more carbohydrates - exacerbating a vicious cycle in the metabolism: the more carbohydrate consumed, the more hunger is triggered, the more calories consumed, the higher blood sugars, the more insulin demanded, the more cells ignore the insulin, the fatter one gets as excess glucose must be shuttled from the blood and is deposited in body fat, the sicker one gets.

The only way to stop that cycle is to stop feeding it - reduce demand for insulin by reducing blood sugars created by excessive carbohydrate intake. An amazing thing happens when one reduces their intake of carbohydrate - they typically reduce calorie intake without specifically trying to create a calorie deficit or count calories; their blood sugars stabilize, their insulin levels stabilize, their cholesterol levels improve; their blood pressure normalizes and they lose weight.

The leading medical organizations and government agencies call this an unbalanced diet and an unhealthy way to eat.

What do you call it?

Wednesday, June 28, 2006

Enough is Enough

Earlier this week, the American Heart Association updated its dietary guidelines with a number of notable improvements, but one glaring flaw - a recommendation to reduce intake of saturated fat to less than 7% of calories. A number of researchers and scientistist are wondering "where is the evidence?" to support such a recommendation on a population-wide basis.

Today, Dr. Gil Wilshire, shares his thoughts with us in this space in a guest editorial.

ENOUGH IS ENOUGH
Gil Wilshire, MD, FACOG

As I get older and a bit wiser, I have learned to let emotions simmer down a bit before putting thoughts to paper. Restraint of tongue and pen is a true virtue. Suffice it to say that the recent AHA recommendation to further reduce dietary saturated fat consumption has left me angry, dumbfounded, and very frustrated. Now that I have had a chance to absorb this news, I believe I can now calmly formulate an intelligent response.

My thoughts gelled last night as I read the Skeptic column in this month's Scientific American magazine. The author of this monthly piece, Michael Shermer, quotes Francis Bacon thusly:

The human understanding when it has once adopted an opinion (either as being the received opinion or as being agreeable to itself) draws all things else to support and agree with it. And though there be a greater number and weight of instances to be found on the other side, yet these it either neglects and despises, or else by some distinction sets aside and rejects, in order that by this great and pernicious predetermination the authority of its former conclusions may remain inviolate. (Novum Organum, 1620)

Clearly, what was true in 1620 remains true today. Once people's minds are made up, they see what they want to see, and they gather information in a selective way.

Low-fat dietary recommendations were born in the late 1950's out of the work of Ancel Keys. Although we can now see that these studies were fatally flawed by selection bias and confounding variables, the "conclusions," which were actually inferences, were widely accepted. In the past, this phenomenon of acceptance of an authority opinion was common at this time. Healthcare workers and policy makers were generally unaware of the concept of evidence-based medicine, let alone the rigor of Level 1 evidence; that is prospective, randomized human studies.

Now it is 2006, and the low-fat and cholesterol dietary recommendations of Keys remain essentially unchanged, except for the fact that the extremists are now becoming ever more so. We are now experiencing the full onslaught of what Bacon so aptly described as "pernicious predetermination."

What I find so alarming and disturbing is the fact that in the past half century NOT ONE SMIDGEN OF LEVEL 1 EVIDENCE HAS BEEN GENERATED TO SUPPORT THESE RECOMMENDATIONS. I don't know how to say it any louder or clearer.

Virtually everything I do in my medical practice must have rigorous scientific validation before I use it on a patient. Why should public dietary advice be an exception?

My levels of alarm and frustration are very high. If people can convince themselves to drink cyanide-laced Kool-aid, I consider that to be their choice and their problem; but in this analogy, the powers that be want all the rest of us to drink it too! The low-fat proponents consider their position to be so obvious that it does not need any scientific validation. I'm sure they believe their position much the same way when people believed the sun revolves around the earth. It's just obvious, no?

I now live and work in my newly adopted state of Missouri. They have a great motto around these parts: "Show Me." Please somebody, anybody, show me a body of Level 1 (or well-done Level 2) evidence that supports low fat and low cholesterol dietary recommendations for the population at large! Show me some high-quality data. Show me that someone has bothered to properly test the 50 year-old hypothesis.

In the absence of this information, I would like to make the following recommendation:

AN IMMEDIATE MORATORIUM ON ALL POPULATION-WIDE DIETARY RECOMMENDATIONS THAT LACK SUPPORT FROM WELL-PERFORMED, PROSPECTIVE, EVIDENCE-BASED HUMAN STUDIES.

Sanity in this field will only come out of a complete overhaul. We need to tear down the current edifice of confusion to its most basic foundations, and rebuild it from the bedrock up.

As a side note, I am not blind to the ramifications of my statements. The thought of six billion or so apex predators (which we are) returning to a diet we evolved to eat is a very scary proposition. The current ravages of the bush meat trade in Africa would be trivial in comparison to the carnage wrought by billions of hunters on a global landscape. It is likely that Homo erectus has caused numerous mass extinctions of prey species in the past from uncontrolled hunting. Numerous animals and large fish are currently undergoing decimation.

I also wish nothing ill upon our grain farmers. I now live in the Heartland, and one would be hard-pressed to find a more honorable and hard-working bunch of people anywhere in the world. I understand the economic implications of a shift back to meat-based protein food sources would be profound.

Nevertheless, if a grain-heavy food pyramid is being promoted because it is in our country's best economic interests, then just tell me and also communicate this to the American public. I'm actually OK with that. I am willing to put environmental stewardship ahead of my personal interests, just don't call it good nutrition, evidence-based, a balanced diet or healthful eating and expect me to buy it or promote it to patients with chronic disease.

We are in a health crisis in the United States. Surely, with all of our accumulated knowledge and wisdom, we can find a workable solution that is supported by evidence, is economically feasible and returns our population to good health.

Tuesday, June 27, 2006

Demand Accountability from the AHA

Over the last few days, since posting my challenge, to anyone out in cyber-space, to create a menu within the new 2006 American Heart Association (AHA) Diet & Lifestyle Guidelines and meet all essential nutrients as established by the Institute of Medicine, I've received more than a dozen menus. All within the calorie level (1956-calories for a female, age 30, BMI 24.99, light active) and also within the limit of less than 7% saturated fat. Those submitting a menu are finding however, their attempt to meet all essential nutrients is impossible within the restriction of saturated fat.

The AHA remains silent on an individuals ability to follow their guideline. They have not provided the public with a sample menu as a guide, have not detailed what types of foods are required to meet their guideline and have not even offered a single-day menu as proof it can even be done.

For the American public - the target of this new guideline - this should be a wake-up call to demand accountability from the AHA. When an organization, held in high esteem as the AHA is, recommends a particular dietary approach, the public deserves to know what it takes to follow the guideline, what is the scientific basis of the guideline, and what is the real risk, the real potential consequence to health, if one doesn't follow the guideline.

Without this vital information, the public is left with no real help to modify their diet for the better and is set up for failure.

Without this important information, the public is left helpless to help themselves.

Which begs the question, is that the point?

The AHA has a responsibility to each and every person in the United States when it issues a population-wide dietary recommendation; it has an obligation to detail how to follow the guideline and meet nutritional requirements; it has a duty to provide the public with access to the scientific evidence it analyzed to reach its guideline; and it holds the burden of proof to show the public that their recommendation not only reduces health risks when followed, but leads to improved long-term health outcomes.

At present, the AHA is not providing the public with any useful information to follow their guideline and has not established there is a scientific basis for limit on saturated fat that supports its recommendation on a population-wide basis.

You know what I call that? A population-wide experiement without consent.

The public must start to demand evidence, demand accountability and demand workable solutions to our national health crisis. Don't leave the AHA the option, in years to come, to opine "if only the public would follow the guidelines..."

It's time to demand they show us how to follow the guideline, provide a real example of how to eat according to the guideline and meet all nutrient requirements, and provide quality evidence that following it for the rest of our life will reduce risk and improve long-term health outcomes!

Monday, June 26, 2006

Personal Responsibility & Health

An article in EurActiv.com - Obesity debate: personal responsibility needed - caught my attention last week with the opening sentence, "Scientists wish to bring some 'common sense' to the debate on obesity: no need to demonise sugar or any other food as a culprit for obesity - the problem remains imbalance of energy intake and consumption."

Last week EU and US scientists gathered at an event titled "Managing Sweetness" and developed a consensus statement defending the role of sugar in a balanced diet. They argued for bringing personal responsibility back to the core of public health policy and called on the EU and the member states to take the lead in shaping strategies to help individuals learn to manage their diets.

Some background, the Managing Sweetness event is the second one hosted by Oldways Preservation Trust - the first was held in Mexico City, October 21-23, 2004. That conference also led to the creation of and publication of a consensus statement regarding sugars in the diet. Interestingly, the Oldways website has no information about the current conference on their website - nothing, not even the date or location. But with the article above, we know the event took place and that it was hosted again by the Oldways Preservation Trust.

So what are we to make of this new - still unreleased - consensus statement?

We have a good idea of what's to come - managing weight is all about personal responsibility for consumption of sugars and total calories in the diet. Everything, including sugars, in moderation is just fine and dandy. Don't ask for a definition of "moderation" - that's part of the personal responsibility required of anyone taking responsibility for what goes in their mouth.

Which begs the question, how many times are we going down this path before we take a long hard look at the metabolic consequence of excessive carbohydrate in the diet and its direct influence on hunger and appetite?

How much longer are we going to capitulate to the politics that are beneath the surface in this type of consensus statement?

How much longer are we going to appease the food industry and put the financial health of food manufacturers ahead of the health of our adults and our children?

The idea that many "experts" still continue to hold the opinion that it's just a matter of willpower to simply eat less calories, that if one just takes "personal responsibility" and eats "everything in moderation" they'll lose weight...well, it just mystifys me how, after decades of this idea making the rounds while at the same time not working for millions of people, we're still stuck on it.

Of course personal responsibility does come into play - we each choose what we will eat each time we're hungry. However, the influence a food has on our metabolic response is tied to a number of things - calories, weight of food and beverages consumed, macronutrients in food consumed, micronutrients delivered in food consumed, etc. Basically, once we've made a conscious decision about what to eat, our metabolism then takes over and we are no longer consciously "in control" of what happens next. When hunger is triggered a few hours after eating, there is only so long a person can and will ignore the very real, very physical signals the body is sending to urge consumption of more food.

Now the experts, backed by the food industry, are counting on you to eat everything in moderation, even if the very things triggering your hunger are making it difficult to eat less. When you can't, when your hunger is too intense, it's your own fault. It's not the excessive sugars, it's not the food you're eating - it's your fault, your lack of personal responsibility and will power.

Personally, I don't buy it.

As I said, there is a level of personal responsibility involved, but where is the integrity of these experts to tell you how different foods are affecting your metabolism, affecting your hunger triggers, affecting your level of satiety? Where is their personal responsibility to communicate the science honestly to you, the consumer?

Why do these esteemed professionals not communicate about the satiety value of quality protein? Oh, if they did, you'd consume less calories, less food and may even feel better. But, you'd also be eating less processed food, less added sugars and spending less money on the very foods your body no longer hungers for.

Why do these experts not communicate the various data from studies that finds if you consume less carbohydrate, you're more likely to spontaneously - without specifically being told to do so - lower calorie intake? Could it be that you'd again be eating less food, less processed foods and less of the very things that trigger your hunger to eat more?

So while the experts are continuing to push this idea of personal responsibility, isn't it time they took some themselves and told the truth? The truth that what you eat now has a powerful effect on when you'll be hungry again and what you'll be likely to choose to eat later?

Sunday, June 25, 2006

The Challenge Continues...

The first menu received, just hours after posting my $1,000 Challenge, was created by a VP of Nutrition with one of the major online diet sites:

Breakfast: Oatmeal (regular), Walnuts, Skim Milk and Blueberries

Lunch: Turkey breast, Salad Greens, Tomatoes, Broccoli Florets, Olive Oil & Vinegar

Dinner: Red Wine, Baked Salmon, Sweet Potatoes, Carrots, Spinach, Hummus, Cantaloupe

Snacks: Yogurt, Orange, Almonds & Raisins

With 1950-calories and less than 7% saturated fat the above menu met the AHA Diet and Lifestyle Guidelines. However, it failed to meet the DRI for Vitamin D, so I didn't analyze further for other essential vitamins, minerals, trace elements, EAA or EFA levels.

Please note, I am not including the quantity of food to eat in the menus I'm posting. The reason - the challenge must be fair. Those seeking to prove a menu can be created with less than 7% saturated fat and provide all essential nutrients must do it themself without starting with someone else's failing menu!

So, the challenge remains open - no menu has been received that meets the new AHA guideline and provides all essential nutrients!

Thursday, June 22, 2006

New AHA Diet & Lifestyle Recommendations: The $1000 Challenge

This week, the American Heart Association (AHA) revised it's 2000 Dietary Guidelines with a new title and updated recommendations. The 2006 American Heart Association Diet and Lifestyle Recommendations include the following major changes:

  • including "lifestyle" in the title to emphasis the importance of diet and lifestyle
  • minimizing the intake of food and beverages with added sugars;
  • emphasizing physical activity and weight control;
  • eating a diet rich in vegetables, fruits and whole-grain foods;
  • avoiding use of and exposure to tobacco products;
  • achieving and maintaining healthy cholesterol, blood pressure and blood glucose levels; and
  • further reducing saturated and trans fatty acids in the diet

The media has focused its attention on the stricter limit for trans-fats to less than 1% of total calories in the diet. None in the mainstream media seem to be asking about the new stricter guideline for saturated fat - the new recommendation is to limit saturated fat intake to less than 7% of total calories. And let's be clear, it's not 7% or less saturated fat - it's a very clear recommendation to consume less than 7% of energy from saturated fat. The omission of the little "equal sign" under the "less than" sign makes this a "less than" recommendation, not an "equal to or less than" proposition.

To achive this, one must strictly limit consumption of animal foods and regular dairy. There is no way around it when we consider that every liquid oil provides some saturated fatty acids along with the monounsaturated and polyunsatured fats. Basically, this particular guideline is establishing a population-wide recommendation to move to a vegetarian diet without stating it as such.

What's very troubling with the recommendation is that there is no clear, convincing evidence that reducing saturated fat intake to less than 7% of daily energy will prevent chronic disease, improve quality of life in the long-term or increase life expectancy.

After pondering how to communicate how the new stricter limit on saturated fat is dangerous, I concluded I could write, write, write and bore you to death with statistics, data and decades of research findings - or - I could get to the point very quickly with some basic, public information and add a simple challenge to readers.

First some basic information:

On average, as the statistics from 1970-2000 highlight, we've increased our consumption of carbohydrates - significantly - along with our intake of overall calories; our intake of fat, saturated fat and protein has remained more or less stable. In fact, men actually reduced both fat and saturated fat as percentage of their daily calories and in absolute grams eaten each day.

As a nation, our dietary modifications have made us fatter, more have developed Type II Diabetes, and significantly more are taking one or more prescription drugs each day (in 2000, 44% of the population), and an alarming number require three or more prescription medications each day (in 2000, 17% of the population).

We have to ask, what will happen if we do manage to convince the population to reduce saturated fat even more?

Based on studies that have investigated the role of saturated fats in our metabolism, we must ready ourselves for larger numbers of people with nutrient deficiencies, especially the fat soluable vitamins; growing numbers suffering with obesity and insulin resistance, leading to more people with Type II Diabetes; a greater reliance on prescription medication to alleviate the chronic conditions caused by our diet; and more foods touting the benefits of their "low-fatness" to convince you to eat more of it instead of eating animal foods that have saturated fat.

The fact is, limiting saturated fat to less than 7% of calories will directly reduce intake of critical essential micronutrients, fatty acids and amino acids; reduce the absorption of essential fat soluble vitamins; and inhibit the absorption of important minerals. We know this - it's found in numerous studies and surveys. Data from nutritional surveys of people in the US continue to show nutrient deficiencies.

That will only be exacerbated even more if they strictly limit saturated fat to less than 7% of calories.

Now the challenge:

I contend, one simply CANNOT plan a day's menu for a eating and keep saturated fat at less than 7% of energy while at the same time meet essential nutrient-requirements for fatty acids, amino acids, vitamins, minerals and trace elements.

It can't be done.

Take a look at the AHA document, full-text this time - there is not one example of how to eat within the document. No example menu to show following their dietary recommendation will provide for all essential nutrients. No example menu to even show how to eat according to their new guidelines.

Why?

It can't be done and meet nutrient requirements.

So, my challenge is - if someone can prove me wrong - create a menu with about 2,000-calories (the IOM establishes a 30-year old female with a BMI of 24.99 who is "low-active" requires 1,956-calories per day), using common whole foods and that menu conforms to the new AHA recommendations, I'll eat my words, issue a public written apology and reward the person with $1000.00.

Yup, if someone can create a menu, I'm willing to pay to see it.

The AHA didn't think it important to take the time to show anyone reading their recommendations HOW TO DO IT, so I'm willing to here if someone creates a one-day menu and sends it to me and it's within the AHA guidelines. Sad when you think about it - the AHA has the in-house experts on hand to do so!

Heck, they even have menus in their No-Fad Diet book...oh, wait, those menus don't conform to their new guidelines and have way too much trans-fats! But, I digress...

Anyone up for the challenge?

Here are the specifics the menu must include, to conform to the AHA guidelines:

  • 1,956-calories from food and beverages detailed with quantity to consume
  • No vitamin supplements may be included to meet essential nutrient DRI's, the AHA specifically recommends foods for meeting nutritional needs
  • Essential nutrients must provide atleat 98% of DRI: Recommended Intake for Individuals based on a female, 30 years old
  • Essential nutrients not to exceed established Upper Tolerable Limits for a female, 30 years old
  • Less than 7% of calories from Saturated Fat
  • Less than 1% of calories from Trans-fats (industrial and naturally occuring)
  • Total Fat - no specific limit
  • Whole Grain foods must be included as part of grains included
  • Vegetables must be included and may be fresh, frozen or canned
  • Fruits must be included and may be fresh, frozen or canned
  • Dairy must be included
  • Nuts, Seeds, Legumes, lean meats, poultry and fish allowed in menu
  • Added Fats and Oils - depends on what you can fit in with 1,956-calories
  • Added Sugars - allowed, but keep to a minimum, especially beverages
  • Cholesterol - no more than 300mg
  • Sodium - no more than 2300mg
  • Alcohol - no more than one serving (4-oz wine, 12-oz beer, 1.5-oz hard liquor)
  • July 18, 2006: Must comply with the AHA guideline to include a wide variety of foods

You can email your submissions for review and analysis. I'll maintain this challenge online through August 31, 2006. Foods included in the menu must have a nutrient profile available in the USDA Nutrient Database for analysis. Only one submission per person (or organization) allowed.

Over the next few weeks and months I'll present menus submitted along with analysis to determine if it meets nutrient requirements and conforms to the AHA recommendations. If anyone creates a menu that conforms to the above, you'll know when I make a public written apology here on my blog and cut a check to the person who created the menu.

Good Luck!

UPDATE: July 18, 2006

The American Heart Association has placed a page on their website with a general guideline of how many servings of each food group to eat daily (or weekly) as part of a diet that complies with their new 2006 Diet and Lifestyle Recommendations issued last month. Because my challenge requires those submitting menus to comply with the AHA guidelines, the foods included in the menu must comply with this additional information. This guideline is similar to the two dietary patterns the AHA pointed to in their full-text paper previously.